Nov 19th, 2026

Voir Dire

Voir Dire: Examining Dealership Decisions

Pronounced “vwah deer.”

It’s a French legal term which means “to speak the truth.”

The term is most commonly used during a jury selection process where the attorneys question potential panelists about their prejudices or biases and their ability to be fair and especially impartial.

The real truth here is it is very difficult to be neutral, fair, and objective.

Said another way, it’s easy to convince yourself that you are impartial and you’re really not. It’s a similar concept to “confirmation bias.” Interestingly, the Googles tell us “understanding…common biases is the first step toward mitigating … negative impacts.” (You know, I’m all about mitigating negative impacts.) Confirmation bias is giving greater weight to information that confirms your existing beliefs and ignoring other data or evidence which may challenge that belief. Often, the result is poor because you’re not able to be objective.

In a courtroom, voir dire is meant to expose bias before it matters. In a dealership, bias often goes unexamined until it becomes evidence.

It’s worth saying again -it’s very difficult to be unbiased.

Let’s bring this back to daily operations at a dealership. Have you asked yourself if your daily tasks, chores, and responsibilities are compliant and within acceptable tolerances? Employees often do not ask that question of themselves until someone else is asking them for important answers.

Are you able to be open minded and even handed in your questioning yourself? Can you accept the truths before you? Or do you have a bias such that you may not understand the exact situation you’re in?

Few situations start with bad people waking up intending to break the law. They start with reasonable people making reasonable exceptions — usually in the name of efficiency, production, or survival.

Here’s why I’m asking these questions. More and more, government regulators are holding owners, executives, or employees personally liable for the company’s actions. Examples follow.

In October 2023, the FTC and the State of Wisconsin brought a civil action against Rhinelander Auto Center, its current and former owners, and General Manager Daniel Towne. The agencies alleged unlawful fees and discriminatory financing practices. Court orders followed, and the FTC later sent more than $1 million in refunds to consumers.

In December 2024, the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) and the Attorney General of Illinois brought a civil case against Leader Automotive Group companies, their parent company, and former U.S. operations executive James Douvas, alleging deceptive practices. The corporate defendants agreed to a $20 million settlement. That settlement did not resolve the claims against Douvas. That FTC case is pending as they are suing him for $216 million.

In August, 2025, a jury convicted Mark Janbakhsh, CEO & Owner of Auto Masters for Conspiracy to Commit Bank Fraud, Bank Fraud, Making False Statements to a Bank, Bankruptcy Fraud, and Making a False Statement Under Oath. According to the evidence, Janbakhsh conspired with his brother, Ron Janbakhsh, and others in the company to submit false documentation to Capital One to artificially inflate the value of the company’s collateral which would allow Janbakhsh to draw on lines of credit he was otherwise not entitled to take. During the course of the scheme, Auto Masters fraudulently obtained approximately $26.4 million that it was not entitled to receive.

Once bank auditors began to investigate financial discrepancies in Auto Masters’ submissions, the evidence showed that Janbakhsh directed company employees to delete data, emails, and other company information that would have shown his fraudulent dealings. Auto Masters declared bankruptcy in 2017 and, according to the evidence at trial, Janbakhsh lied about the fraud while under oath during the bankruptcy proceedings.

In January 2026, Janbakhsh was sentenced to 42 months in federal prison.

In December 2025, federal prosecutors charged Daniel Chu, the former CEO of Tricolor Holdings, LLC, and David Goodgame, the former COO, with fraud-related offenses. Prosecutors alleged a scheme involving the double-pledging of collateral and the manipulation of loan information. Former CFO Jerome Kollar and former finance executive Ameryn Seibold pleaded guilty in December 2025. Reuters reported that Goodgame pleaded guilty in June 2026. The charges against Chu are allegations, not a finding of guilt.

These cases involve different facts and outcomes, and raise questions about what executives knew and the decisions they made. What we are talking about is all about self-responsibility, no matter your job title.

There are plenty more examples and the list isn’t slowing down.

Think these sound extreme? Doesn’t sound like anything you’re familiar with? Good.

Big problems start really, really small. A mistruth here or there… Not being completely candid with a customer or your boss about any particular situation.

Voir dire isn’t about catching someone in a lie. It’s about creating a moment where the truth has a chance to surface before it’s too late.

Compliance failures don’t begin as scandals. They begin as exceptions. A fee that isn’t fully explained. A number that gets rounded. A process that works “most of the time.”

The question isn’t whether regulators will ask hard questions. They will.

The real question is whether you’ve already asked them of yourself — honestly, completely, and without defensiveness. Because when accountability finally shows up, it rarely starts with the company. It starts with the person who thought they were being reasonable.

Voir dire is what happens when someone else examines your decisions for bias, intent, and truth.

The safest position isn’t believing you’re compliant. It’s constantly proving that you are — to yourself first.

Tom Kline DMM Expert

Tom Kline

DMM Expert

Protecting Dealers' Business, Reputation & Legacy

Tom Kline is the Dealer Bodyguard delivering peace of mind and a better night’s sleep for dealers.

A former dealership owner with more than 30 years of retail experience, nationally recognized expert

witness, and Founder of Better Vantage Point, Tom helps dealerships identify risk before it becomes

litigation, regulatory action, financial loss, or headline news. His work is built around one mission: Protect

the House.

For more than three decades, Tom has guided dealer principals, executive teams, attorneys, and insurance professionals through some of the industry's most complex legal, operational, insurance, and compliance challenges. He has served as an expert witness in high-profile litigation involving the nation's

largest dealership groups and is regularly retained to evaluate dealership operations, defend business practices, and identify vulnerabilities before they become costly problems.

Tom is also the creator of the Tuck The Octopus℠ System, a practical philosophy for managing the countless "tentacles" of dealership risk. Through his books, Tuck The Octopus℠ and The 10 Minute Tuck, he equips dealership leaders with practical, ready-to-use tools that build stronger cultures, improve compliance,

reduce losses, and create organizations that consistently outperform reactive competitors.

Known for making complex compliance topics understandable, and even enjoyable, Tom combines real dealership experience with humor, memorable storytelling, and practical systems that employees actually remember long after the training ends. His philosophy is simple: It's Better to Train Than Explain.

Whether serving as a Fractional Risk & Compliance Executive, keynote speaker, consultant, expert witness, or trusted advisor, Tom ensures dealerships:

Protect their people.

Protect their reputation.

Protect their profits.

Protect the House.

Tom believes the best lawsuit is the one that never happens. His philosophy is simple: anticipate risk, build a culture of accountability, and make protecting the house everyone's responsibility.

Tom Kline | Better Vantage Point, LLC
📱 (757) 434-7656
📧 [email protected]
🌐 bettervantagepoint.com
▶️ YouTube Channel

🛡️ We Get You Out Of Trouble...And Keep You Out Of Troubleˢᵐ

🐙 Tuck The Octopusˢᵐ

📊 Get Kraken On Compliance!ˢᵐ

View full profile

Get Curated Insights

Content worth the click

Stay Ahead of the Curve

Get exclusive insights, expert advice, and the latest trends in automotive marketing delivered straight to your inbox.

Join over 10,000 automotive professionals